Stewart Jaffy & Assoc., 306 E. Gay St., Columbus OH 43209
Sign up for our free Ohio Workers' Compensation Quarterly email

XML/RSS
Posted: November, 1999

Court Indicates Psychiatric Exclusion Unconstitutional

Bailey v.Republic Engineered Steels, Inc., et al. (11/1/99), Stark Co. App. No. 1999CA-00084.

Note: The Ohio Supreme Court accepted an appeal from this decision and ruled that the injured worker could receive workers' compensation, but did not find the psychiatric exclusion unconstitutional.

This case involves a psychiatric-only claim. [A psychiatric-only claim occurs where there is a psychiatric problem without a physical injury.] The injured worker suffered the psychiatric injury as a result of accidently running over a co-worker with a tow motor.

The injured worker's claim had been disallowed because there is an exclusion in R.C. 4123.01(C) which provides
"Injury" does not include:

 (1) Psychiatric conditions except where the conditions have arisen from an injury or occupational disease;
The Court of Appeals in its decision indicated that this exclusion of psychiatric-only claims violated the Constitution. The Court indicated that the psychiatric exclusion violated Equal Protection. The Court also indicated (at page 8 of its decision) that
We find the denial of compensation of employees who suffer psychiatric conditions which do not arise from a compensable injury to or occupational disease suffered by that employee is inherently unfair and contrary to the purposes of compensating workers as set forth in Section 35, Article II of the Ohio Constitution.
The Court then determined to interpret the statute in a different manner than other courts, in order to provide coverage to the injured worker. The Court indicated that R.C. 4123.01(C)(1) refers to a psychiatric condition which arose from "an injury." The Court found that there was "an injury" in the present case because the worker who was run over by the tow motor was injured. Therefore, the Court indicated that the claim was compensable under the Ohio workers' compensation system.

This information was provided courtesy of the Ohio Workers' Compensation Bulletin.
Common Ohio Workers' Compensation Terms Explained

Injured at Work?


Stewart Jaffy & Associates can help you receive the workers’ compensation benefits you are entitled to.  We are based in Columbus and represent injured workers throughout Ohio before the BWC, Industrial Commission and in court.

We also represent people who have social security disability claims or who have a disability claim before another state administrative agency (PERS, STRS, SERS or police and fire fighters disability).

Initial consultations with potential clients are free.  If you are interested in talking with us about a potential case, call us at (614) 228-6148. 
Stewart Jaffy & Associates Co., LPA | Attorneys at Law 
306 E. Gay St. | Columbus, OH 43215
Telephone: (614) 228-6148 | Fax: (614) 228-6140 
http://www.jaffylaw.com


  Please read our legal notice.